Many drivers believe that taking their car to the dealership for repairs is the safe choice or the only option. The truth is that dealerships are adept at presenting themselves as the one place that thoroughly understands your vehicle, especially if it's still under warranty.
But once the warranty expires, or sometimes even before, the dealership becomes one of the most expensive places for routine maintenance or repairs. A dealership service department's job is to maximize revenue, and they are typically not concerned with efficiency and affordability.
Here's why getting your car serviced anywhere except the dealership can save you money and cause you less stress.
Dealership Charge Premium Prices
Dealerships have a reputation for high overhead costs, including large service bays, expansive and branded facilities, franchise fees, and corporate requirements. They pass on these costs, rather than absorb them.
In some cases, labor rates can be close to double what you'd pay at an independent auto shop. Even routine services like oil changes or brake replacements can come at a higher cost. Most drivers don't realize that technicians across the industry receive the same training, use comparable tools, and follow the same manufacturer guidelines.
Independent Mechanics Offer More Transparent Service
Dealerships operate on volume. They want to move as many vehicles as possible, and aren't overly concerned with offering personalized service. They can rush diagnostics, focus more on upselling than repairing, and do what they can to inflate a bill.
Independent shops thrive on building long-term relationships with their customers. They aren't bound to corporate quotas and sales goals. They rely on their reputation and customer loyalty. This means you are more likely to receive honest assessments, fair pricing, and direct communication with your mechanic.
Most independent shops also offer cheaper yet high-quality aftermarket options, which is a level of flexibility that many dealerships don't have.
Jimmy Nilsson Masth on Unsplash
You're Not Handcuffed By Your Warranty
One of the biggest myths that drivers believe is that servicing your vehicle outside of your dealership will void the warranty. This is not true. According to the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, manufacturers are not allowed to require you to exclusively use your dealership for repairs or servicing to maintain warranty coverage.
Independent auto shops are more than equipped to handle routine maintenance, scheduled service intervals, minor and major repairs, and any diagnostic work that's required. A good independent mechanic will follow your vehicle's maintenance schedule closely while ensuring that your warranty remains intact.
Another factor to consider is that many aftermarket warranties work directly with independent shops, not dealerships, giving you more options to save money without sacrificing quality.
Dealerships rarely offer better prices and more choices. Refusing to take your vehicle to a dealership for every repair is one of the best decisions a car owner can make. Independent mechanics are more likely to offer better pricing and more personalized service without impacting your warranty. Relegate going to your dealership only for recall work or a very specialized issue. Otherwise, find alternatives that will save you money and make sure your car runs as it should.
